logo
Weather page
GET THE APP
ePaper
google_play
app_store
  • Login
  • E-Edition
    • Marketplace
  • News
  • Sports
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion
  • Classifieds
    • Place an Ad
    • All Listings
    • Jobs
  • Special Sections
  • Photo Gallery
  • Contests
  • Lifestyle/Entertainment
  • Games
    • News
      • Local News
      • PA State News
      • Nation/World
    • Sports
      • Local
      • College Sports
      • State
      • National
    • Obituaries
    • Opinion
      • News
        • Local News
        • PA State News
        • Nation/World
      • Sports
        • Local
        • College Sports
        • State
        • National
      • Obituaries
      • Opinion
    logo
    • Classifieds
      • Place an Ad
      • All Listings
      • Jobs
    • E-Edition
      • Marketplace
    • Subscribe
    • Login
      • Classifieds
        • Place an Ad
        • All Listings
        • Jobs
      • E-Edition
        • Marketplace
      • Subscribe
      • Login
    Home News W.Pa. parents sue state officials, UPMC over refusals to grant mask exemptions
    W.Pa. parents sue state officials, UPMC over refusals to grant mask exemptions
    News, PA State News
    October 22, 2021

    W.Pa. parents sue state officials, UPMC over refusals to grant mask exemptions

    By TORSTEN OVE Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

    PITTSBURGH (TNS) — Parents in nine Western Pennsylvania communities have sued state officials and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center over school district COVID-19 mask mandates, saying schoolchildren are being improperly denied medical exemptions from masks.

    The suit was filed in U.S. District Court on Wednesday by Butler lawyer Alexander Lindsay. It names Alison Beam, the secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Health; Sherri Smith, deputy secretary for the Office of Elementary and Secondary Education in the state Department of Education; and UPMC.

    Beam in August issued an order requiring students to wear masks in school.

    Part of the order allows for an exception if wearing a mask causes a medical condition, makes an existing one worse, or creates a mental health issue.

    In September, Smith told school districts that the Department of Health order was “not a mask-optional policy” and said any schools that permit a parent “sign-off” without medical evidence is not in compliance with the order and could be open to legal action.

    As a result, according to the lawsuit, school districts have “rigorously demanded that any parent seeking an exemption for a medical condition must have medical evidence, including medical records from the affected child’s pediatrician or a treating physician.”

    Parents seeking an exemption have been told by their pediatricians or personal physicians that UPMC and other large health care providers are not supporting exemption requests.

    ”Throughout Western Pennsylvania, school administrations are sending children home, segregating them in schools, subjecting them to abuse on the part of teachers and other students and otherwise making it impossible for them to get a public education as guaranteed by the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,” the lawsuit says.

    The ten plaintiffs — nine parents and one guardian — are from Kittanning, New Castle, Leechburg, Johnstown, Grove City, Apollo, Rural Valley, McKeesport and Hastings.

    The complaint describes various medical problems of students in those communities and their alleged need to be exempt from masks.

    In one case, the parents of a 9-year-old girl in the New Castle Area District who has social anxiety and attention deficit disorder said they tried to get an appointment with the girl’s pediatrician and psychiatrist to get an exemption.

    The doctors’ offices told the father they couldn’t schedule an appointment because of the huge number of parents trying to get exemptions.

    The girl went to school on Sept. 7, and a school official told her father she’d have to be picked up because she didn’t have a mask. The next day, she went to school without a mask again, and her father went to see her pediatrician to get an exemption. The doctor told him the office couldn’t provide one because they were “not ready to put their license to practice on the line” by signing an exemption, according to the suit.

    The father then tried to get an exemption from the girl’s psychiatrist, but the doctor declined to meet with him, the suit said.

    The school called him and told him to pick her up. When he got to school, he said, the school nurse told him the girl was showing COVID symptoms. She ended up in quarantine for 10 days.

    On Sept. 20, the girl went to school again, this time with a “religious exemption,” but the district told the father it was unacceptable and she would have to be picked up.

    The father couldn’t go and get her, so the district separated the girl from her class and told her parents that she would be suspended for three days for her refusal to wear a mask. The district said she would be expelled if she kept coming to school without one.

    In the end, the parents enrolled her in a cyberschool, according to the suit, “to avoid the inevitable expulsion for failure to wear a mask.”

    In another case, the guardian of a 17-year-old student in the Leechburg Area School District with ADD and anxiety issues tried to get an exemption from Children’s Hospital doctors, “but the doctors refused to sign an exemption for fear of being sued,” the suit said.

    The boy refused to wear a mask and at school on Sept. 8 asked to go to the bathroom. When a teacher escorted him, he said, “This is retarded.”

    He ended up suspended for the remark and for refusing to wear a mask, according to the suit.

    The suit argues that state officials do not have authority to issue a school mask mandate because that power rests in the hands of school boards.

    The complaint raises a claim under the Rehabilitation Act, a federal law guaranteeing that people with disabilities cannot be denied participation in any program receiving federal money, such as schools.

    It also brings a claim under the 14th Amendment, which guarantees due process and equal protection, saying the districts are depriving students with disabilities of an education.

    The complaint is seeking an injunction against the defendants declaring that they are in violation of the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act by maintaining a policy of refusing exemptions.

    The suit is also asking that the August order by the secretary of health and the September communication from the secretary of education be voided.

    Tags:

    alexander lindsay civil law doctor exemption law legislation medicine official school sherri smith suit

    The Bradford Era

    Local & Social
    ePaper
    google_play
    app_store
    Latest news for you
    Portion of Genesee Mills Road to close for resurfacing
    Local News
    Portion of Genesee Mills Road to close for resurfacing
    July 10, 2025
    CLEARFIELD – The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) announced the next portion of Genesee Mills Road (Route 1010) in Bingham and Harr...
    Read More...
    {"to-print":"To print", "bradfordera-website":"Website"}
    Local outdoors columnist wins multiple awards
    News, Outdoors
    Local outdoors columnist wins multiple awards
    By WADE ROBERTSON 
    July 10, 2025
    Once a year in May, the Pennsylvania Outdoor Writers Association holds its annual meeting and awards banquet. This takes place at a different location...
    Read More...
    {"to-print":"To print", "bradfordera-website":"Website"}
    Rinsing recyclables in dishwater
    Lifestyles
    Rinsing recyclables in dishwater
    July 10, 2025
    Dear Heloise: I, too, live in Tucson, Arizona, and follow the same ritual for rinsing recyclables in dishwater as J.B. I also put some items in the di...
    Read More...
    {"to-print":"To print", "bradfordera-website":"Website"}
    Boyfriend’s daughter complicates long-term relationship
    Lifestyles
    Boyfriend’s daughter complicates long-term relationship
    July 10, 2025
    DEAR ABBY: I have been seeing my partner, "Gil," for five years. After my husband passed, Gil came into my life again. We had been colleagues about 10...
    Read More...
    {"to-print":"To print", "bradfordera-website":"Website"}
    ‘Round the Square: More Mount Gretna missives, part 1 of 2
    Round the Square
    ‘Round the Square: More Mount Gretna missives, part 1 of 2
    July 10, 2025
    ANOTHER: The Era received a second letter from Orderly L.M. Peterson, sent from the Pennsylvania National Guard training grounds at Camp Miner, Mount ...
    Read More...
    DIFFERENCE MAKERS: ‘Be(ing) the change’
    Local News
    'Be(ing) the change'
    DIFFERENCE MAKERS: ‘Be(ing) the change’
    Cinda Roberts doesn't hesitate to help
    By SAVANNAH BARR s.barr@bradfordera.com 
    July 10, 2025
    Cinda Roberts believes that everyone should help where they can and, as Gandhi encouraged, "be the change you wish to see in the world." Roberts knows...
    Read More...
    {"newsletter-daily-headlines":"Daily Headlines", "newsletters":"Newsletters", "to-print":"To print", "bradfordera-website":"Website"}
    This Week's Ads
    Current e-Edition
    ePaper
    google_play
    app_store
    Already a subscriber? Click the image to view the latest e-edition.
    Don't have a subscription? Click here to see our subscription options.
    Mobile App

    Download Now

    The Bradford Era mobile app brings you the latest local breaking news, updates, and more. Read the Bradford Era on your mobile device just as it appears in print.

    ePaper
    google_play
    app_store

    Help Our Community

    Please help local businesses by taking an online survey to help us navigate through these unprecedented times. None of the responses will be shared or used for any other purpose except to better serve our community. The survey is at: www.pulsepoll.com $1,000 is being awarded. Everyone completing the survey will be able to enter a contest to Win as our way of saying, "Thank You" for your time. Thank You!

    Get in touch with The Bradford Era
    Submit Content
    • Submit News
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Place Wedding Announcement
      • Submit News
      • Letter to the Editor
      • Place Wedding Announcement
    Advertise
    • Place Birth Announcement
    • Place Anniversary Announcement
    • Place Obituary Call (814) 368-3173
      • Place Birth Announcement
      • Place Anniversary Announcement
      • Place Obituary Call (814) 368-3173
    Subscribe
    • Start a Subscription
    • e-Edition
    • Contact Us
      • Start a Subscription
      • e-Edition
      • Contact Us
    CMG | Community Media Group
    Illinois
    • Hancock Journal-Pilot
    • Iroquois Times-Republic
    • Journal-Republican
    • The News-Gazette
      • Hancock Journal-Pilot
      • Iroquois Times-Republic
      • Journal-Republican
      • The News-Gazette
    Indiana
    • Fountain Co. Neighbor
    • Herald Journal
    • KV Post News
    • Newton Co. Enterprise
    • Rensselaer Republican
    • Review-Republican
      • Fountain Co. Neighbor
      • Herald Journal
      • KV Post News
      • Newton Co. Enterprise
      • Rensselaer Republican
      • Review-Republican
    Iowa
    • Atlantic News Telegraph
    • Audubon Advocate-Journal
    • Barr’s Post Card News
    • Burlington Hawk Eye
    • Collector’s Journal
    • Fayette County Union
    • Ft. Madison Daily Democrat
    • Independence Bulletin-Journal
    • Keokuk Daily Gate City
    • Oelwein Daily Register
    • Vinton Newspapers
    • Waverly Newspapers
      • Atlantic News Telegraph
      • Audubon Advocate-Journal
      • Barr’s Post Card News
      • Burlington Hawk Eye
      • Collector’s Journal
      • Fayette County Union
      • Ft. Madison Daily Democrat
      • Independence Bulletin-Journal
      • Keokuk Daily Gate City
      • Oelwein Daily Register
      • Vinton Newspapers
      • Waverly Newspapers
    Michigan
    • Iosco County News-Herald
    • Ludington Daily News
    • Oceana’s Herald-Journal
    • Oscoda Press
    • White Lake Beacon
      • Iosco County News-Herald
      • Ludington Daily News
      • Oceana’s Herald-Journal
      • Oscoda Press
      • White Lake Beacon
    New York
    • Finger Lakes Times
    • Olean Times Herald
    • Salamanca Press
      • Finger Lakes Times
      • Olean Times Herald
      • Salamanca Press
    Pennsylvania
    • Bradford Era
    • Clearfield Progress
    • Courier Express
    • Free Press Courier
    • Jeffersonian Democrat
    • Leader Vindicator
    • Potter Leader-Enterprise
    • The Wellsboro Gazette
      • Bradford Era
      • Clearfield Progress
      • Courier Express
      • Free Press Courier
      • Jeffersonian Democrat
      • Leader Vindicator
      • Potter Leader-Enterprise
      • The Wellsboro Gazette
    © Copyright The Bradford Era 43 Main St, Bradford, PA  | Terms of Use  | Privacy Policy
    Powered by TECNAVIA